Environmental
stresses can make changes to the way we act in our lives. One environmental
stress that can have a negative impact on our lives is cold. The body’s
homeostasis is disturbed when an aspect of the internal environment goes
outside of its normal limits. Cold temperature affects this in many ways. For
example when we are cold, our body will constrict blood vessels to reduce heat
loss. In extreme cases this can lead to loss of blood in the extremities of our
body. This also leads to rising blood pressure, in response out kidneys will
pull out excess fluid to reduce the pressure and which leads to urination many
more times when it is cold. A full bladder is a place for extra heat loss, so
urinating conserves heat yet this also causes a loss of fluids from the body.
Humans have the habit
of shivering when they are cold, which is a short term adaptation. When people
shiver, muscles vibrate which heats the body.
A form of facultative
adaptation is vasoconstriction, which is the narrowing of the blood vessels to
reduce blood flow to the skin. It is an instinctive response to cold, and
reduces heat loss from the skin’s surface. This can also be dangerous, because prolonged vasoconstriction can cause complete loss of blood to the extremities (hands and feet).
A form of developmental adaptation is seen when
looking at populations as a whole. People who live in cold environments tend to
have shorter and rounder bodies. They are shorter because their hearts do not
need to work as hard to pump blood to the hands and feet. These people are
rounder/ heavier because their bodies gather fat around their vital organs to
insulate the heat. Their bodies also resort to using this fat for energy.
Two cultural
adaptations are seen with clothing and food. People who live in countries where
the temperature is extremely low have apparel which consists of think clothing
made of fur or wool to maintain their warmth. They also eat foods with high fat
and calorie content. This increases their basal metabolic rate, which in turn
creates extra body heat. During the cold
weather, people slept in close huddles.
Race can be used in different manners to understand the variations of adaptations. For example the cultural adaptations, can vary between different regions. Some people may resort to eating meats high in fat content where as other people may not eat meat but instead rely on other foods high in fat and protein. People's body shapes also make a difference. The woman pictured under developmental adaptation, shows the characteristics of living in an environment where people over time have grown shorter, and gain fat in different patters. Environmental influences is a better way to understand human variation rather that the use of race. This is because the environment reflects what happens with a persons body. A country has people of the same race, but each region of this country has different environmental pressures. One may be hot and another cold, affecting the physical appearance of the person and their diet. If we claim they are the same race so their variations will be the same, we are wrong.





In general, you started off well with your background on cold stress, but is higher urination rates the worst think that can happen to you when you get cold? How about hypothermia and death? I appreciate the detail, but make sure you finish the story!
ReplyDeleteGood short term adaptation.
Yes, prolonged vasoconstriction is dangerous. How does the body respond to reduce this danger? The answer is another example of a facultative trait.
Good discussion on the long term adaptation, but actually the body does its best NOT to use the body fat since that is needed for insulation. Consuming the body fat is a last resort, used only if food intake drops.
Missing the discussion on the advantages of the environmental approach. You jump right into a comparison of race and adaptive approaches.
"Race can be used in different manners to understand the variations of adaptations."
Your examples don't demonstrate this. The examples show differences but they don't offer an explanation of why the differences exist, which is the problem with using race. Race is a subjective, social construct, so how can it be used to objectively understand biological variation? The answer: It can't. It is purely categorical, not explanatory. It has no biological value.
"Race can be used in different manners to understand the variations of adaptations."
This was a really great discussion. I enjoyed your your short term adaptation. You gave good examples following your facts. I feel like you could of did a better job with your variation of adaptation but overall I enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteHello Sandeep,
ReplyDeleteYou have made good points about the cultural adaptations people make to cold temperatures. Most of the time, people wear hats in extremely cold weather. Is that just because a hat feels good? No, wearing a hat serves a vital purpose for the human body in cold weather. The body can lose around 40% of its heat through the head. It is important for the brain not to get cold. Brains like warmer temperatures not colder. Body heat can be lost through the head but also through the neck, the hands and wrists, and the ankles and feet. I know this from camping. Covering those parts of the body helps to maintain a normal body temperature. Sometimes, people wear the wrong clothing in cold weather. They think that putting on layers of warm cotton clothing will keep them from shivering which is the short-term adaptive response to cold that you mentioned in your posting. However, the opposite can happen. The body can get too warm and start to sweat. Rather than shivering from the cold air, the body starts to shiver from the cold sweat on it. This not a good short-term adaptive response for cold environments because it can lead to hypothermia. Dr. Rodriguez points out the condition of hypothermia in her response to you. Hypothermia goes beyond a good short-term response to cold such as shivering and becomes a potential life threatening bodily response. There are special types of clothing that are suited better for being in extremely cold temperatures. Some of those clothes are used by Olympic skiers to keep them from getting too cold or too hot.